Oldschool rohan is pointless as long as playwith exists for one and secondly I enjoy MOST of the post 99 content. Without it I am psure none of us would be playing because as nice as it was there is not really much to do after you get full BiS gear.
What really needs to happen and I am being 100% honest is somebody has to make a game with rohan's pvp system. The only thing that has kept this game alive this long is how damn good the pvp is here compared to every other game.
What I would really want to play one day is a combination of ROHAN, TERA and RS.
The pvp of ROHAN with the TSB system and some of the nice dungeons/lore
Certain pvp mechanics from TERA (staggers and attack speed speeding up skill execution being the ones off the top of my head) as well as pvp to work towards pvp gear (battlegrounds) AND the crafting/gathering system (With 2x-4x the production points of TERA)
The quests/acheivement from RS (quest story lines, worthwhile rewards, unlocking access to resources to make PVE gear and consumables like pots/scrolls/arrows/bolts, acheivement system that earns you a piece of gear that has special uses inside its respective map) Oh and dungeoneering would be awesome (you use the gear you have on instead of starting with 3-4 items) each floor takes like 30-45 mins (make it hard you know) you get 2 floors a day and cash shop lets you reset 2 extra times for example.
I dont want to be able to cut down trees or make fires or stop in the middle of battle to eat an entire shark (lol) but lets say you do some quest series in Gezian it unlocks access to a special garden with several gathering spots for grade A thornbushes which you can refine into grade A thornbush paste, combine the paste with a grade A potion base (costs 1500 gold) to make a grade A health potion. Or after completing the quest series in morrisen (did I spell that right?) you gain access to a dungeon filled with archers that drop specialty bolts/arrows that have uses in pve (chance to bleed/slow aspd/heal/crit) as well as archer's ore which can be refined into pure archer's ore (RNG crit crafting just like TERA) which can be crafted into lvl 120 pvp bolts with a chance to stagger (a stagger is a type of ministun that interupts attacks/skill execution as well as slow for 0.3 seconds or so, you can still pot but a stagger would interupt you casting heal for example)
Wall o text idk was kinda fun just throwing ideas at the wall not like this magic game will ever happen. Until then I just afk outskirts on tera since everyone on my server is 2 scared to duel me. While playing 2-3 hrs of RS a day. Lurk on the forums sometimes watch these sandy vaginas/pinoys/mexicans fail pvp remembering the good ol days when ppl didnt play dirty and playwith wasnt such a pile of greedy sandy vagina scorpions.